Colorgraph Eye Pencil

Its alright

It works, doesn’t glide very smoothly and smudges but in a pinch or for a less precise look this would be sufficient. I don’t think that I would purchase this in the future. Also not as black as I like my black eyeliner but that is preference.

Beautiful pigment

I love this eyeliner! The color is so pretty - like a slightly metallic brown. The application was great and it went on so smoothly with no smudging. It was great for lining my upper lid and I especially loved it in my waterline. Definitely recommend!

Luxurious feel

The Valentino Colorgraph Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil offers a luxurious feel and performs well in terms of ease of use. The soft tip makes application a breeze, gliding smoothly across the lids for a flawless look. It’s particularly great for creating a bold, dramatic effect or a quick everyday line. However, after a few uses, the tip becomes less sharp, which can make achieving precise lines a bit challenging compared to brush-tip alternatives. Additionally, for those with oily skin, the eyeliner tends to smudge slightly after around six hours, which might be a drawback for long-lasting wear. Overall, it’s an elegant and user-friendly product, but it may require some touch-ups and maintenance for optimal performance.

Luxe but limited

Packaging and application were luxe. Waterproof eyeliner held up all day but came off nicely with oil based cleanser. My only complaint was the limited amount of product. Otherwise loved the pigmentation and would use for special occasions.

New Obsession

This eye pencil is my new holy grail. I was curious to try a brown eyeliner, as a less harsh alternative to a black pencil. I love it even more than I would have thought. Like this pencil even more because of the brown has a bit of shimmer, not completely matte. And the brush at the other end is great for smudging.

Amazing Eyeliner

I love this eyeliner! It is the perfect neutral brown shade with a little shimmer. Goes on smoothly and blends out so nicely with the included blending brush. Has great pigmentation and stay power! I have watery eyes from wearing contacts and I did not have any smudging or running. Will definitely be using this as my go-to eyeliner!

Best, long lasting, waterproof eyeliner!

Love this eyeliner. It is so easy to apply, and stays on all day! My only issue is that I am finding it hard to sharpen. Because it has a bit of a gel texture, it gets stuck in my normal sharpener. Wonder if there a sharpener that Valentino sells/recommends for use with this fantastic eyeliner?

Awesome & waterproof FOR real!

Been looking awhile for waterproof eyeliner that can got on the inside on waterline and NOT make my eyes water! This is IT! Love it & generous size, I've never paid a lot for eyeliners and definitely glad I invested in this one. It's awesome, will be buying again for sure

Easy to use!

Love how smoothly this eyeliner goes on! Was so easy to use and blend. Still getting used to using the blending brush on the other end but may be easier for those more skilled with make-up application. Love the shine in the brown color, really compliments my eyes.

Love!

I am really loving this product! This product is so incredibly creamy and pigmented. I was very impressed. I would definitely repurchase in the future.

Glides on, easy to work with

This eyeliner goes on so smoothly, it is very easy to work with. I just had a baby and have no time for makeup but was able to quickly put this on and it flicked out very easily and clean. The attached brush was the perfect consistency to blur without making it appear sloppy. I wore it out on the boat and got rained on and it stayed put all day. Highly recommend.

Beautiful pigmented longwearing eyeliner!

Gorgeous! Luxury, high quality eyeliner with long wear; the shade “brown fondant” is beautiful. You can press harder or apply more to get a darker look, or go light for a lighter shimmer line. Super pigmented, great color payoff! Absolutely love how longwearing it is, I had to rub and rub it to get it to budge! Highly recommend.