Master Mattes® Eyeshadow Palette: The Neutrals

Perfect cool-toned palette

I was in need in a cool-toned palette and this did not disappoint! Shades blend like a dream!

Disappointed

Was disappointed with this eye shadow palette. There was no color payoff. I had to apply several layers to even see any eye shadow, even with primer. Not worth the price.

Gorgeous palette + highly pigmented

I got this palette because it was hyped up and I obviously caved. Overall it’s a very pretty palette and is very pigmented compared to cheaper brands. The reviews which say this is too chalky etc, are mostly by people who tap their brushes way too hard on the colors. And those who say it doesn’t blend well are most likely people who press their brush too hard down on their lids. Overall it’s a nice palette but it lasts on my eyes about the same amount of time as a drugstore palette does. The only difference is at the end of the day, it doesn’t leave a darkly pigmented crease like drugstore colors would (my lids get oily throughout the day and the color builds up into the crease)

Da BEST!!!

Excellent. The only shadow that completely sets my kohl eyeliner so that it doesn’t budge if I RUB IT—including the softest, prettiest pencil on the market. Lovely colors with nice payoff. I have pink-toned skin and oily lids, and only need a smattering of powder to prep. Highly recommended!!!

Don't waste your money.

Does not go on smoothly. Very small palette for the price. Even with primer, I have to work hard to get the color even. I've used drug store eyeshadow that is better. Very disappointing.

Love love

A staple palette in a makeup artist kit. The perfect neutrals to use

Only used eyeshadow palette of 2024

I am not a huge lover of eyeshadow and for the most part only just wear mascara and a little bit of brown eyeliner when I put makeup on. However, I have lately been craving a more elevated eye look but still want to keep things simple. I decided to buy this after seeing people rave about it and use it to recreate 90s eye makeup. I can honestly say it has become my favorite if not only eyeshadow palette I have used consistently for the year. I also love it because I use all of the shades, not just a few which is usually what happens with a palette with a lot of colors. The formula is very pretty, blends very easily and is very easy to use, even for those of us who aren't good with eyeshadow. It's also great because it's not too warm or cool so I don't have to worry about it clashing with my blush or lip looks. Definitley a favorite and would highly recommend.

Pretty good

Recently added this palette to my collection and I do enjoy it. I have VERY fair skin and I like the way these colors look on my eyes, however the pigment is very soft. If you have a deeper skin tone, the color payoff might now be up to parr.

In theory this was the perfect palette for me. I was super excited since it’s all mattes which I love. But it’s hard to get pigment on the eyes and all the colors end up looking the same on the lid even if I try to pack it on. I also do agree there’s a lot of fallout in the pan.

Go-to

Love this eyeshadow palette. I use all the colors and they blend so easily.

had to try it cause of billie eilishhhh. best thing ever. ty billie

Worth the price

I can’t believe this was actually worth the price… but it was. The color payoff is incredible and the palette is full of the perfect neutrals.