No 1. Pencil Creamy Long-Wearing Eyeliner

Broke on first use

The formula of the eyeliner resulted in the tip breaking off on the first use. I attempted to sharpen it but any time the eyeliner is exposed in the pencil, it broke off more. It’s a sticky, crumbly formula. Gorgeous color but will not purchase again.

not super durable on its own, but works well with eyeshadow:) easy to apply and blend

Long wearing, stays put

I liked this liner and would buy again! Great color and really stays in place.

LASTS ALL DAY!!!

I love this eyeliner!!! I prefer pencils over liquid! This last me all day, no smudges and easy to apply!!!

Broken :(

Didn’t even get a chance to wear! Tip was broken off and discovered product inside tube was broken when I tried to sharpen, total waste of money and massive disappointment.

Awful

Wish I had read the reviews first. The first use was ok but when I tried to sharpen, it stuck in 4 diff sharpeners! Waste of money. Will return.

Fun!

These eyeliners deserve more hype! There are so many fun shades making them perfect for fun looks. But you can also use them for natural makeup looks to add a fun pop of colour or just by using the more natural shades. The pencils themselves are very creamy and bendable to apply!

my fav eyeliner

First off it’s soooo easy to use, it’s super creamy and pigmented. It’s sharpenable, and you can twist it up. It’s really long lasting and amazing for the price point (compared to other eyeliners at Sephora) Really the only downside is the packaging gets kind of messy, but it’s nothing major

Not my fave

Wanted to love this but it’s too think and doesn’t smudge/go on smoothly.

New favourite

Product glides on easily and lasts all day. I was worried that at such an amazing price, the product would smudge and transfer/bleed onto my upper eyelid, but it doesn’t!! High recommend this eyeliner.

Long lasting! Colors differ from photos though.

I got these pencils in Ochre, Muse and Kiln. Pros: The pay of is great. No smudge on my hooded eyes, and they last a while! So I'm very happy. Cons: Although Ochre and Muse are the same color as advertised, I'm afraid I can't say the same for Kiln. The latter looks like a nice hot red but in person, it is just Terracotta. So if you are looking for a red pencil, don't bother with Kiln.

most eyeliners are hard to put in my waterline, this formula is the most pigmented pencil I have found that doesn't run in my waterline