Superhero No Tug Liner

Should be called Much Tug Eyeliner

I can’t believe this is called No Tug. Tugging is required. Other than that, it’s fine. Wears pretty well. Nice color.

Meh

did not like the espresso color, looked more like a raisin color. It was not a smooth applying eyeliner, definitely wish I returned this product

Worst eyeliner. Does not go on smooth. And you have to sharpen it, constanyou. I have great gel eyeliners, that you just turn the bottom. This one is not worth the money..

Very difficult to sharpen without wasting the product

Waste of Money. It breaks often when sharpening. Had to throw it away after using it once. Would never buy this brand again.

Sharpens okay

I was a little hesitant to buy this pencil, given all the reviews that say it doesn't sharpen. But I bought a Sephora brand pencil sharpener and it worked fine. The pencil is reasonably sharp, draws a clean line, and stays put all day.

Don't buy

It goes on super smooth, but once you need to sharpen it, the gel crayon breaks off and it gets all over the sharpener. Like other users have said, it's too soft to hold up to sharpening. It's a waste of money because it breaks off more often than you'll be able to use it, and it begins to flake.

Worst eyeliner ever

This is the worst eyeliner ever. I bought this cause of the good reviews but it’s terrible. It glides on smooth but starts to flake during the day. It’s going in the trash.

Flakes and doesn’t go on in a continuous line

Flakes all over your eye area and in your eyes as well! I spent most of my time cleaning that up. Also, does NOT go on in a single clean line; it “skips” and leaves places blank that you need to fill with another black eyeliner. Finally, what actually was on my eyelid and not in my eye didn’t last very long, maybe 2 hours. Won’t buy again, it was a waste of money. Into the garbage it goes!

Useless product

This eyeliner is like a wax crayon. It may not "tug" but it also doesn't glide any color on your lids. My upper eyelid (under the lashes) can accept the color but it doesn't stay on long. Bottom lid won't accept or hold the color at all.

I only used for a couple weeks and all of a sudden the whole gel liner came out and it’s not retractable and there’s not enough sticking out that I could even sharpen it. Very disappointed. I realize this may be a fluke but still very disappointed I can’t use it anymore

Difficult to remove

After double cleansing meticulously, little particles of this eyeliner can still be found under my eyes. Leaving residual makeup overnight is a big no-no. If I rub any more my eyes will be raw. Will not repurchase.