PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil

It is so pigmented but it does smear very easily. The small tip makes it easy to apply.

No this doesn’t stay on the waterline

I believed the reviews. This does not stay on your waterline. Within an hour it was in the corner of both eyes just a giant glob. I don’t have watery eyes and I actually even dried my waterline before application. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Not waterproof and smudged terribly on me.

I ordered 2 of these eyeliner pencils, one in brown and the other in black. After 2-3 hours, the eyeliner had smeared terribly, leaving me raccoon eyes. I had thought these were advertised as "waterproof/smudge-proof" but sadly I didn't find this to be the case. It wasn't like I was outside involved in sports and sweating I was inside the whole time having lunch with a friend and there should've been no reason for these to smudge as terribly as they did. Very disappointed. If eyeliner is prone to smudge on you I would look elsewhere for another brand.

I really like the Blk Coffee but it’s just too expensive for an eye pencil. I have quite a few of her other products, so I don’t mind paying a bit more, but this isn’t worth it in my opinion.

skip

this is my second time buying the black eyeliner. I thought I'd give it another chance, and yet I remember why I never purchased it again. it doesn't stay. it bleeds. I don't like it and hate that I wasted my money. the brown one is fine, although I wish it was a bit deeper, but the black liner, it's a no-go.

So rich !

So I use this as a lip liner. Sometimes eyes. I’m finally writing a review because I carelessly lost my pencil. It is truly a great brown. As a dark skin woman I appreciate the pigmentation it gives off.

Love ❤️

Finally, a suitable replacement for my beloved Marc Jacobs Truffled fineliner which was discontinued. This is a beautiful, creamy rich brown that is saturated enough to use with any of my shadows.

Glides on smoothly.

Love the dark brown. That perfect shade between black and brown. Glides on smoothly. Very creamy feel. Long wearing. I just don’t get the wear time on other brands like I do with Pat McGrath eyeliners.

doesn’t stay in place

I was willing to pay more for an eyeliner that would have a smooth application and stay in place. This isn’t it— with liner only on the top lid, not in waterline, And no mascara on, I had eyeliner under my eyes on a warm day. Heed this warning before you spend this much on a product whose quality is lower than that of a drug store.

stays in place

I ordered this online and I was disappointed when I searched this on my hand because it disappeared when I touched it BUT somehow it stays perfect in place on my eye. Just don’t be discouraged if you swatch it in store bc it stays well on the eyes! I thought there would be more shimmer in this but it’s still pretty.

An excellent liner works great...but is very pricey,

self purchased

I’m only taking one stay off because mine didn’t come with a sharpener. However, it’s a great liner. I use it for my top waterline, it has a bit of transfer though.